Whether your Bay Shore house is a tidy ranch or a place that hasn't been touched in 30 years, Tony the Cash Guy will buy it. Cash. No inspection. No clean-out. No fees. Tony buys throughout Suffolk County, New York — and we close at a local title company in 7 days.
The kind of cape property Tony buys throughout Bay Shore.
Suffolk County is eastern Long Island: Babylon, Brookhaven, Smithtown, Islip, plus the Hamptons and North Fork. Beach houses and inherited family homes are core to Tony's Suffolk volume.
Suffolk tax rates are 2.0-2.5% on the South Shore and lower on the East End.
Hamptons and North Fork closings often involve out-of-state owners; Suffolk title companies handle remote signings routinely.
§·· / Schedule
Tell Tony where the house is and what shape it's in. Get a cash number on the same call. Pick a closing date.
7 days a week, 8 AM to 9 PM Eastern.
Tony's been buying houses in Suffolk County, New York since 2018. Every single offer is made directly by Tony — not a call center, not a lead form, not a bot. You call, Tony picks up, you tell him about the Bay Shore property, he gives you a number. If the number works, you set a closing date that fits your schedule. Most sellers pick a date 7 to 14 days out.
Bay Shore has turn-of-the-century Victorians and colonials on the streets around Main Street and south toward the bay, 1920s–50s capes and colonials in the middle of the hamlet, waterfront houses south of Montauk Highway that flooded in Sandy, and 1960s–70s ranches and hi-ranches in North Bay Shore near the Sagtikos, where unpermitted apartments are common. Older two- and three-families cluster near downtown and the hospital.
Bay Shore sellers call Tony with a Victorian near Main Street that a parent held for fifty years and never updated, an estate in Riverhead, and heirs who don't agree; a bay-front cape south of Montauk Highway that Sandy flooded and NY Rising never finished raising; or a North Bay Shore hi-ranch with a basement apartment and a Town of Islip code case. Some are landlords done with a two-family near the hospital. Tony buys the Victorian with the belongings, the unraised bay house, and the hi-ranch occupied — one number on the phone, closing on the family's date.
Bay Shore sellers pay the 0.4% New York State transfer tax; Tony's offer is net of it. Town of Islip closings hinge on the certificate of occupancy and rental permits for every apartment and extension — a bank buyer makes you legalize them, and Tony buys "as-is C of O" for cash. Everything south of Montauk Highway is in a FEMA flood zone, which matters to a lender and not to Tony. Deeds record with the Suffolk County Clerk in Riverhead, and Suffolk Surrogate's Court there handles Bay Shore estates.
§·· / Schedule
Tell Tony where the house is and what shape it's in. Get a cash number on the same call. Pick a closing date.
7 days a week, 8 AM to 9 PM Eastern.
Yes. Sight-unseen offers are how Tony does most Suffolk County deals. Tax records, deed, New York comp data, and your description over the phone — that's all Tony needs to give you a real cash number for your Bay Shore home.
No. Many Suffolk County sellers hand Tony the keys with the house exactly as their parent or grandparent left it. Furniture, clothes, the works. Tony's crew clears everything out post-closing.
Most Bay Shore closings happen in 7 to 14 days from first phone call. With clean title and a motivated seller in Suffolk County, Tony has closed in 5 days at the local title company.
No. Tony covers Suffolk County title insurance, New York transfer taxes (in most cases), and all closing fees. The cash quote you hear on the phone is what hits your hand for your Bay Shore property.
Yes. Tony has bought houses in Suffolk County that were partly burned out, flooded, or condemned by New York inspectors. As-is means as-is. Insurance check or no insurance check — Tony still buys.
Tony works with Bay Shore and Suffolk County sellers facing foreclosure all the time. The New York title company can pay off your mortgage and any back taxes at closing — you walk away clean, often with cash on top.
If you're in probate or estate proceedings in Suffolk County, having an attorney is wise. New York title companies handle the paperwork either way; many Bay Shore sellers close without a lawyer when the title is clean.
Yes. Bay-front and canal-side houses in Bay Shore that were flooded, patched, and never elevated are exactly what Tony buys. He needs no elevation certificate and no flood insurance because there's no lender. Tell him what was repaired, whether NY Rising was involved, and what's still open with the Town, and he gives you a number.
Yes — all of ZIP 11706, from the ranches and hi-ranches of North Bay Shore to the Victorians around Main Street, the two-families near South Shore University Hospital, and the waterfront south of Montauk Highway. One call with the address gets you a number.
No. Tony buys Bay Shore houses with unpermitted basement, garage, and second-floor apartments, occupied or empty, and takes on the Town's code-enforcement case after closing. A bank buyer's lender would refuse the file; Tony pays cash and prices it honestly. Don't remove the kitchen before you call.
Once the court in Riverhead issues letters, the executor or administrator can sign a contract with Tony, and a firm cash number often ends the disagreement — each heir sees exactly what they'll net. Heirs anywhere sign with a notary and get wired. Tony buys the house with everything still in it, so nobody has to spend weekends clearing it out.
One phone call to Tony at 1-908-768-4759 turns your Bay Shore, New York house into cash in your hand. Leave the rest behind — Tony handles it.
Contact
Drop your number and Tony reaches out within the hour.
§·· / Schedule
Tell Tony where the house is and what shape it's in. Get a cash number on the same call. Pick a closing date.
7 days a week, 8 AM to 9 PM Eastern.
Photos shown represent property types similar to recent purchases. Specific addresses and seller names are withheld for privacy.
Newark, NJ
Inherited from mother — full of belongings
Closed in 9 days
Brooklyn, NY
Tenant-occupied — closed without eviction
Closed in 11 days
Teaneck, NJ
Senior downsizing — moved to assisted living
Closed in 14 days
Pick whichever situation matches yours — same Tony, same cash, different angle.