How much commission do I save by selling my Montauk house to Tony directly?
5-6% of sale price. On a $300K Montauk house, that's $15,000-$18,000. On a $500K, $25,000-$30,000. You keep all of it.
Get Cash for My House — No Realtor, No Commission in Montauk, NY
Real estate agents charge 5-6% commission. On a typical Suffolk County sale that's $20,000-$40,000 gone before you see a dime. Tony charges nothing. The cash quote is the cash you keep on your Montauk property.
- Save 5-6% commission ($15K-$30K typical)
- No listing agreement, no exclusivity
- No staging, no showings, no open houses
- No agent picking sides at the negotiation
- Direct sale, direct closing, direct check
The kind of shore bungalow property Tony has bought in Montauk.
Suffolk County Market Context
Suffolk County is eastern Long Island: Babylon, Brookhaven, Smithtown, Islip, plus the Hamptons and North Fork. Beach houses and inherited family homes are core to Tony's Suffolk volume.
Suffolk tax rates are 2.0-2.5% on the South Shore and lower on the East End.
§·· / Schedule
Sell Without a Realtor in Montauk — Call Tony Now
Tell Tony where the house is and what shape it's in. Get a cash number on the same call. Pick a closing date.
7 days a week, 8 AM to 9 PM Eastern.
How Sell Without a Realtor Works in Montauk
Why do agents in Montauk push for a price reduction after 30 days on the market? Because their job is to close — yours or someone else's. Their commission is the same whether your house sells for $400K or $375K. Tony's offer is direct; there's no agent incentive working against you.
How a Cash Offer on a Montauk House Is Actually Built
Every cash buyer, Tony included, starts from the same three numbers: what the house would sell for fully renovated, what it costs to get it there, and how long that takes. The offer is that finished value minus the repairs, minus the buyer's resale costs and margin. In practice that lands most cash offers somewhere around 70–85% of the renovated value, less repairs. The honest comparison is not against a renovated house's list price — it is against what you would actually net from a NY listing after commission, repairs, and months of carrying costs.
| Line item | List with an agent | Sell to Tony |
|---|---|---|
| What the house would sell for fully renovated | $400,000 | $400,000 |
| Repairs a retail buyer's lender will demand | − $45,000 | Tony's problem |
| Agent commission (5–6%) | − $20,000 to $24,000 | $0 |
| Inspection credits, seller closing costs, concessions | − $8,000 to $12,000 | $0 |
| Taxes, insurance, mortgage, utilities while you wait (3–6 months) | − $9,000 to $15,000 | $0 |
| Time to cash in hand | 4 to 7 months | 7 to 14 days |
| What you actually walk away with | ≈ $305,000 to $318,000 | Tony's number, in full, on your date |
Whether Tony's number beats that listing net depends on the house. On a move-in-ready home in a hot NYmarket it usually will not, and Tony will tell you to list. On a house that needs work, has tenants, sits in an estate, or carries violations — the houses retail buyers cannot finance — it is often close, and the seven-day timeline is the difference. Call 1-908-768-4759, get the number, and compare it yourself.
Buying since 2018· every county in New Jersey and New York · no commissions or fees · every closing at a licensed NY title company.
Contact
Don't Want to Call Yet? Tony Will Call You.
Drop your number and Tony reaches out about your Montauk property within an hour.
Questions From Montauk Sellers
Don't I need an agent to find a buyer in Montauk?
Tony is the buyer. There's no buyer to find — you're calling the buyer directly. No MLS, no Zillow listing, no showings.
What about MLS exposure for my Montauk house?
MLS exposure is how agents find buyers. Tony doesn't need it because Tony already has cash and is already the buyer. The whole reason for MLS evaporates.
Won't I get less by skipping the agent in Montauk?
Sometimes a tiny bit less, sometimes more. The commission savings often more than offset any difference. And if your Montauk house needs work, has a complication, or just needs to sell fast — the agent route nets you less in the end.
Do I need to sign anything before talking to Tony about my Montauk house?
No listing agreement. No exclusivity. No "right to sell." You call, Tony makes an offer, you decide. If you say no, you owe nothing — there's no contract until you sign one at closing.
Skip the 6%. Call Tony at 1-908-768-4759. Direct sale on your Montauk house — no agent in the middle.
§·· / Schedule
Get a cash offer right now.
Tell Tony where the house is and what shape it's in. Get a cash number on the same call. Pick a closing date.
7 days a week, 8 AM to 9 PM Eastern.
Other Ways to Sell in Montauk
Different situation? Tony also handles these Montauk cases:
- We Buy HousesWe Buy Houses in Montauk, NY for Cash — Any Condition
- Sell My House FastSell My House Fast in Montauk, NY — Cash in 7 Days
- Sell As-IsSell Your Montauk, NY House As-Is — No Repairs, No Cleaning
- Sell an Inherited HouseSell an Inherited House Nobody Wants in Montauk, NY — Cash,
- Stop ForeclosureStop Foreclosure on Your Montauk, NY House — Cash, Walk Away
- Sell a House Full of StuffSelling a House Full of Stuff in Montauk, NY — Tony Takes Ev
- Probate Property SaleProbate Property Sale in Montauk, NY — Cash, Attorney-Friend
- Get a Cash OfferGet a Cash Offer for Your Montauk, NY House — Same Phone Cal
- Sell My Rental PropertyTired of Being a Landlord in Montauk, NY? Sell Your Rental f
- Sell a Fire-Damaged HouseSell a Fire-Damaged House in Montauk, NY — Cash, As-Is, No R
- Sell a Vacant PropertySell a Vacant Property in Montauk, NY — Stop the Carrying Co
- Senior DownsizingSenior Downsizing in Montauk, NY — Sell Your House to Tony f
- Divorce House SaleDivorce House Sale in Montauk, NY — Cash, Fast, Court-Friend
- Behind on Property TaxesBehind on Property Taxes in Montauk, NY? Tony Pays the Taxes
- House with Code ViolationsHouse with Code Violations in Montauk, NY? Tony Buys It As-I
- Relocating for a JobRelocating from Montauk, NY? Sell Your House Fast for Cash
- Sell a Water-Damaged HouseSell a Water-Damaged House in Montauk, NY — Cash, As-Is, No
- Sell a House with MoldSell a House with Mold in Montauk, NY — Cash, No Remediation
- Sell from Out of StateOut-of-State Owner Selling in Montauk, NY? Tony Closes Remot
- Short SaleShort Sale on Your Montauk, NY House — Tony Pays Cash, Walk
Sell Without a Realtor — Nearby Towns in Suffolk County
← All cash buyer options for Montauk·Suffolk County·New York